9 Best Compatible Toner Cartridges (October 2026)

The best compatible toner cartridges include the Canon Genuine 067 Black Toner Cartridge Compatible for Canon home offices, the Cool Toner TN227 TN-227BK/C/M/Y High Yield Toner Cartridge for Brother color printing, and the Cool Toner 218X Toner Cartridges 4 Pack for HP frequent printing.

On this page (8 sections)

1. How to choose the best compatible toner cartridges
2. Compatible toner cartridges by printer family
3. How do you compare toner yield and pack size?
4. Are compatible cartridges a good value?
5. When should you choose genuine toner?
6. How do you install and care for a toner cartridge?
7. What mistakes should you avoid when buying toner?
8. Which compatible toner cartridge should you choose?

The best compatible toner cartridges match your printer’s exact model and toner number. This guide compares compatible color sets for Brother, Canon and HP printers, plus genuine cartridges for buyers who prefer supplies from their printer’s brand.

Toner compatibility is model-specific. Before comparing yield or pack size, confirm the toner family your printer uses with our guide to what toner does my printer use.

These picks cover several printer families, so they are not interchangeable. A TN-227 set for select Brother printers will not fit an HP or Canon printer, even if the cartridges share the same colors.

Our picks at a glance

1. 1
   Best for Canon home offices

   Canon Genuine 067 Black Toner Cartridge Compatible

   9.7/10 our score

   See it on Amazon
2. 2
   Best for Brother color printing

   Cool Toner TN227 TN-227BK/C/M/Y High Yield Toner Cartridge

   9.6/10 our score

   See it on Amazon
3. 3
   Best for HP frequent printing

   Cool Toner 218X Toner Cartridges 4 Pack

   9.5/10 our score

   See it on Amazon

4. 4

   Brother Genuine Standard Yield Toner Cartridge

   Best for Brother mono documents
   Check it
5. 5

   TRUE IMAGE 067 067H Toner Cartridge Set

   Best for Canon color households
   Check it
6. 6

   Canon Genuine 069 Black Toner Cartridge Compatible

   Best for Canon office printing
   Check it
7. 7

   TRUE IMAGE 206A Toner Cartridges 4 Pack 206X

   Best for HP color documents
   Check it
8. 8

   Valuetoner Compatible Toner Cartridge for Canon

   Best for legacy Canon printers
   Check it
9. 9

   HP 218A

   Best for HP original supplies
   Check it

How to choose the best compatible toner cartridges

Choose by exact printer model and toner family first, then compare cartridge type, colors, yield and the number of cartridges in the pack. For a model-specific example, see Brother HL-L2460DW toner replacement.

Compatibility is the first filter because a high-yield cartridge has no value if it does not fit.

We compared printer compatibility, cartridge type, stated page yield and whether each option is black-only or a color set. The genuine Canon, Brother and HP choices give you a point of comparison if buying from the printer brand matters to you.

Page yields are estimates under stated coverage conditions. Learn what high-yield toner means before comparing capacity.

Print settings, graphics and the amount of text or color on each page affect how quickly toner runs out.

The product cards give the printer models and cartridge families to check. For a broader comparison of best laser printer toner cartridges, explore other options for laser printers.

Compatible toner cartridges by printer family

Choose toner by your printer series and cartridge family. For a model-specific example, see HL-L2405W toner replacement.

The Brother, Canon and HP sets below each serve specific models, and the model name should match before you place an order.

1

Canon Genuine 067 Black Toner Cartridge Compatible: Best for Canon home offices

9.7/10Our score

• Black cartridge
• For Canon LBP633Cdw, LBP632Cdw and MF650 series models
• Up to 1,350 pages

A single black Canon 067 cartridge for select Canon imageCLASS and LBP models. Check your printer’s exact model before choosing it.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Canon genuine cartridge
• Model compatibility is specified
• Stated yield for black

Cons

• Black only
• Limited to listed Canon models

Canon’s genuine 067 black cartridge is for select LBP630 and MF650 series models. It’s a single black cartridge, suited to a black toner replacement rather than a full color set.

Canon specifies a yield of up to 1,350 pages for black. Compatible models include LBP633Cdw, LBP632Cdw, MF652Cdw, MF653Cdw, MF654Cdw and MF656Cdw.

Canon warns that non-Canon or refilled cartridges can damage the printer and may affect its limited warranty. Check your printer’s warranty terms before deciding between genuine and third-party toner.

Choose this when you need black Canon 067 toner for a supported printer and prefer a Canon genuine cartridge. Skip it if you need cyan, magenta or yellow, or if your printer uses another cartridge family.

2

Cool Toner TN227 TN-227BK/C/M/Y High Yield Toner Cartridge: Best for Brother color printing

9.6/10Our score

• Four cartridges: black, cyan, magenta and yellow
• For select Brother TN-223/TN-227 printers
• Up to 3,000 black and 2,300 color pages

This compatible four-color set is for select Brother printers that use TN-223 or TN-227 cartridges. Compare the model list and cartridge number before buying.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Four colors in one set
• High-yield option
• Printer models are specified

Cons

• Third-party cartridge
• Fit is limited to listed Brother models

The Cool Toner TN-227 set contains black, cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges for select Brother color laser printers. It also supports specified Brother TN-223 models, so confirm your printer model and cartridge family before ordering.

The stated yield is up to 3,000 pages for black and 2,300 pages for each color cartridge at 5% coverage. That makes it a reasonable match for regular color printing when the printer is on the supported model list.

Supported models include Brother HL-L3210CW, HL-L3230CDW, HL-L3270CDW and MFC-L3770CDW, among others. Match your complete printer model to the compatible model list.

Choose this set for a supported Brother TN-223 or TN-227 printer when you want all four colors in one compatible pack. Skip it if your printer uses TN-730 or if you only want a black cartridge.

3

Cool Toner 218X Toner Cartridges 4 Pack: Best for HP frequent printing

9.5/10Our score

• Four cartridges with chips installed
• For select HP Color LaserJet Pro 3201 and 3301 models
• Up to 3,200 black and 2,500 color pages

A compatible four-color set with chips installed for select HP Color LaserJet Pro models. Verify whether your printer uses the 218X cartridge family.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Chip is included
• Four colors in one set
• Stated high-yield figures

Cons

• Third-party cartridge
• Model compatibility is limited

This Cool Toner four-pack contains HP 218X toner for select Color LaserJet Pro 3201 and 3301 models. Its chips are installed, so you do not need to transfer an original chip.

The stated yields are up to 3,200 pages for black and 2,500 pages for each color cartridge at 5% coverage. Compare those figures with the standard-yield HP 218A set later in this guide, and check that your printer uses the 218X family.

Supported models include the Color LaserJet Pro 3201dw, 3301fdw, 3301cdw and 3301sdw. Match the complete model name to the compatible model list.

Choose this for a supported HP printer if you print frequently and want a compatible high-yield color set. Skip it if your printer does not use 218X or if you prefer original HP toner.

4

Brother Genuine Standard Yield Toner Cartridge: Best for Brother mono documents

9.4/10Our score

• Genuine Brother black cartridge
• For select Brother laser printers
• Up to 1,200 pages

The TN-730 is a genuine standard-yield black cartridge for several Brother laser printers. It suits buyers who want a Brother-branded replacement.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Genuine Brother toner
• Broad listed model compatibility
• Stated yield

Cons

• Black only
• Standard yield

Brother’s TN-730 is a genuine standard-yield black cartridge for several Brother laser printers and all-in-ones. Its stated yield is up to 1,200 pages.

Supported models include DCP-L2550DW, HL-L2350DW, HL-L2370DW, HL-L2390DW, MFC-L2710DW and MFC-L2750DW. TN-730 is a different cartridge family from TN-223 and TN-227, so match the model and number.

For another Brother toner family, see best Brother TN660 toner cartridges.

Brother says Dash Replenishment can automatically reorder cartridges when activated with an eligible printer. This may help you keep a spare supply on hand without tracking each cartridge change.

Choose TN-730 if you need black toner for a listed Brother printer and prefer genuine supplies. Skip it if you need color or a high-yield option.

5

TRUE IMAGE 067 067H Toner Cartridge Set: Best for Canon color households

9.3/10Our score

• Four compatible cartridges
• For select Canon imageCLASS and LBP models
• Up to 1,350 black and 1,250 color pages

This four-color compatible set covers select Canon printers that use 067 or 067H toner. Confirm the model and cartridge family before choosing it.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Four colors in one set
• Stated yield for each color
• Several compatible Canon models listed

Cons

• Third-party cartridge
• Not for every Canon printer

TRUE IMAGE’s 067/067H set contains four compatible cartridges for select Canon imageCLASS and LBP printers. It fits listed models such as the MF656Cdw, MF654Cdw, LBP632Cdw and LBP633Cdw.

The stated yield is up to 1,350 pages for black and 1,250 pages for each color cartridge at 5% coverage. The set includes one black, one cyan, one yellow and one magenta cartridge.

Check whether your printer uses 067 or 067H toner and match its full model number to the compatible model list. This is a third-party full-color set, while the Canon genuine option above is black-only.

Choose this when you need a complete color set for a supported Canon printer and are open to compatible toner. Skip it if you only need black or prefer Canon-branded supplies.

6

Canon Genuine 069 Black Toner Cartridge Compatible: Best for Canon office printing

9.2/10Our score

• Genuine Canon black cartridge
• For LBP674Cdw, MF753Cdw and MF751Cdw
• Up to 2,100 pages

A genuine black Canon 069 cartridge for three specified Canon laser printer models. Check the model number before ordering.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Genuine Canon toner
• Model fit is specified
• Stated black yield

Cons

• Black only
• Limited to listed models

Canon’s genuine 069 black cartridge fits the LBP674Cdw, MF753Cdw and MF751Cdw. It is a single-cartridge option for printers that use 069 toner.

Canon gives a black yield of up to 2,100 pages. This cartridge is not a replacement for 067 toner.

Confirm your printer model before buying because similar Canon model names do not guarantee the same cartridge fit. If your printer uses a different toner number, choose its matching family.

Choose this for a supported Canon printer that needs 069 black toner and you want a genuine cartridge. Skip it if you need a color pack or your printer uses 067 toner.

7

TRUE IMAGE 206A Toner Cartridges 4 Pack 206X: Best for HP color documents

9.1/10Our score

• Four compatible cartridges with chips
• For select HP Color LaserJet Pro models
• Up to 1,350 black and 1,250 color pages

A compatible four-color set with chips for specified HP Color LaserJet Pro models that use 206A or 206X toner. Check your printer’s cartridge family first.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Four colors in one set
• Chips are included
• Model list and yields are specified

Cons

• Third-party cartridge
• Limited to listed HP models

TRUE IMAGE’s 206A four-pack contains black, cyan, yellow and magenta cartridges with chips installed. Compatible models include HP Color LaserJet Pro M255dw, M255nw, M282nw, M283fdn, M283cdw and M283fdw.

The stated yield is up to 1,350 pages for black and 1,250 pages for each color cartridge at 5% coverage. The set is compatible with 206A and 206X toner families, so check your printer’s requirements before choosing it.

TRUE IMAGE provides guidance for certain non-genuine cartridge messages. Check your printer’s warranty terms and the cartridge maker’s support options before you buy.

Choose this if you need all four colors for a supported HP model and want a compatible set with chips included. Skip it if your printer uses the newer 218 family or another toner number.

8

Valuetoner Compatible Toner Cartridge for Canon: Best for legacy Canon printers

9.0/10Our score

• Four black cartridges
• For select Canon imageCLASS, Faxphone and LBP models
• Up to 2,100 pages per cartridge

This four-pack is for select older Canon printers that use Canon 128 toner. Match the complete printer model to the compatibility list.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Four black cartridges
• Several compatible models listed
• Stated yield per cartridge

Cons

• Third-party cartridge
• Model range is specific

Valuetoner’s four-pack contains black Canon 128 cartridges for select Faxphone, imageCLASS and LBP printers. Supported models include the D530, D550, MF4450, MF4570 and LBP6230dw.

Each cartridge has a stated yield of up to 2,100 pages at 5% coverage. Since this is a four-pack, consider how many black replacements you need and whether you have room to store the extras.

For storage guidance, see whether laser toner cartridges dry out.

Match your complete printer model to the compatible model list. Canon 128 is not interchangeable with the 067 or 069 families in this guide.

Choose this for a supported Canon 128 printer when you want several black replacements available. Skip it if your Canon printer belongs to a newer toner family or you need color.

9

HP 218A: Best for HP original supplies

8.5/10Our score

• Four original HP standard-yield cartridges
• For select HP Color LaserJet Pro 3201 and 3301 models
• Up to 1,300 black and 1,200 color pages

This genuine HP four-color set is a standard-yield option for select 3201 and 3301 series printers. It is a useful comparison when weighing compatible toner against original HP cartridges.

See it on Amazon

Pros

• Original HP toner
• Four colors in one pack
• Stated model fit and yields

Cons

• Standard yield
• Limited to listed HP models

HP 218A is the original HP option for select Color LaserJet Pro 3201 and MFP 3301 series printers. This standard-yield four-pack contains black, cyan, magenta and yellow cartridges.

HP gives yields of up to 1,300 pages for black and 1,200 pages for each color cartridge. Compare this set with the compatible high-yield 218X option if you are weighing original HP toner against a compatible cartridge.

Supported printers include the Color LaserJet Pro 3201dw and MFP 3301fdw, 3301sdw and 3301cdw. Match your precise model and toner family before choosing either 218A or 218X.

Choose this when you prefer original HP supplies and your printer uses 218A toner. Skip it if your priority is a higher stated yield and you are open to compatible toner.

How do you compare toner yield and pack size?

Compare the stated yield for each color and count the cartridges in the pack. A four-color set is convenient when you need a full set, but buying all four at once may be unnecessary if you only print in black.

The yield figures in this guide vary by model and cartridge family. Several are stated at 5% coverage, so a page full of graphics or dense text can use toner faster than a mostly blank page.

Consider how quickly you use each color before choosing a pack. Keep the toner number in view when comparing yields, since figures for different cartridge families do not tell you whether the cartridges will fit your printer.

Are compatible cartridges a good value?

A compatible cartridge may be a good value when it fits your printer, meets your print needs and comes with support you trust. Compare the set contents and stated yield, then consider your printer’s warranty terms.

“Compatible” means a third-party cartridge is made for a printer family. It does not mean every cartridge for a brand fits every model.

Some buyers prefer an original cartridge from the printer maker. Others compare third-party sets when they need several colors or want an alternative to OEM toner.

Remanufactured and compatible cartridges are different options: remanufactured cartridges reuse a cartridge that has been cleaned and refilled or rebuilt. See our best remanufactured toner cartridges guide for more on that alternative.

When should you choose genuine toner?

Choose genuine toner when you want a cartridge from the printer brand and the exact OEM model is available for your printer. Canon warns that non-Canon or refilled cartridges can damage its printer and may affect the limited warranty.

That warning matters to Canon owners deciding between the genuine 067 or 069 picks and compatible alternatives. Review your printer’s warranty terms before choosing third-party toner.

Genuine toner may suit you if you prefer supplies from the printer maker. Check the fit, pack size and yield, then decide which option meets your needs.

How do you install and care for a toner cartridge?

Install toner with the printer powered as directed in its manual, and use the cartridge’s model number to confirm the match before opening the package. Keep the work area clear and handle the cartridge carefully to avoid spilling toner.

Follow the printer maker’s instructions for removing the old cartridge and seating the replacement. Avoid touching sensitive cartridge parts, and do not force a cartridge that does not slide into place.

Store unopened cartridges in their packaging in a dry place away from heat and direct sunlight. Keep each cartridge in its protective packaging until you are ready to use it, and follow the manufacturer’s storage instructions.

If prints show streaks or uneven density after replacement, check that the cartridge is fully seated and consult the printer’s own troubleshooting steps. Don’t shake or clean a cartridge unless its instructions recommend doing so.

What mistakes should you avoid when buying toner?

The most common mistake is matching only the printer brand. A Canon cartridge number, Brother series or HP toner family is specific, and similar printer names can use different cartridges.

Avoid assuming that a compatible cartridge will work because the colors or shape look similar. Read the full model list and toner number, including suffixes such as A, X, 223 or 227.

Don’t compare page yield without checking whether it refers to black or each color cartridge. Also check the pack count so you know whether you’re buying one replacement or several.

Finally, avoid opening every cartridge as soon as a multi-pack arrives. Keep unused cartridges sealed until needed, and retain the packaging in case you need to confirm the model number or contact the cartridge maker.

Which compatible toner cartridge should you choose?

Choose the compatible set that matches your printer family: Cool Toner TN-227 for supported Brother color models, Cool Toner 218X for supported HP 3201 and 3301 models, and TRUE IMAGE 067 or 206A sets for the listed Canon or HP printers. For black-only needs, match Canon 067, Canon 069, Brother TN-730 or Canon 128 to your exact printer.

If you print often, compare high-yield choices in our best high-yield toner cartridges guide. For a basic explanation of toner and laser printers, see why laser printers do not use ink cartridges.

FAQ:

Can I refill a laser toner cartridge? You can sometimes refill one, but cartridge design and printer requirements vary.

Our guide explains whether you can refill a laser toner cartridge, including what to consider before trying it.

Our top 3 picks at a glance

1. 1
   Best for Canon home offices

   Canon Genuine 067 Black Toner Cartridge Compatible

   9.7/10 our score

   See it on Amazon
2. 2
   Best for Brother color printing

   Cool Toner TN227 TN-227BK/C/M/Y High Yield Toner Cartridge

   9.6/10 our score

   See it on Amazon
3. 3
   Best for HP frequent printing

   Cool Toner 218X Toner Cartridges 4 Pack

   9.5/10 our score

   See it on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

How do I know which compatible toner cartridge fits my printer?

Find your printer’s exact model and the toner number it uses, then compare both with the cartridge’s compatibility information. Similar model names can take different toner families.

If you’re unsure, start with what toner does my printer use before comparing options.

Are compatible toner cartridges the same as remanufactured cartridges?

No. Compatible cartridges are made by a third party to fit a printer family, while remanufactured cartridges reuse a cartridge that has been cleaned and refilled or rebuilt.

For that distinction and related picks, see our best remanufactured toner cartridges guide.

Should I choose high-yield toner?

High-yield toner may mean fewer cartridge changes if you print often, but check that the cartridge fits your printer and compare its stated yield with your needs. Page-yield figures are estimates under defined coverage conditions.

Our best high-yield toner cartridges guide compares more options.

Can third-party toner affect my printer?

Canon warns that non-Canon or refilled toner can damage its printer and may affect its limited warranty. Review your printer’s warranty terms and the cartridge maker’s support options before choosing a third-party cartridge.